FDA Approval Won’t Save You: How to Patent Digital Health Innovations Before They’re Copied
Created By Patent Lawyers, For Patent Lawyers.
Don’t miss this webinar by our partner PatentPC
Instant watch session available. Join now!
The digital health industry is booming, driven by breakthroughs in telemedicine, wearable devices, remote monitoring, and AI-powered diagnostics. But with growth comes competition, and in such a fast-paced sector, the race to innovate can often feel like a sprint. For many innovators, securing FDA approval is seen as the ultimate milestone. However, it’s a critical mistake to assume that FDA approval alone will protect your digital health innovation.
While FDA approval validates the safety and efficacy of your product, it does nothing to prevent competitors from copying your technology. Without proper patent protection, rivals—or even big players—could swoop in, replicate your idea, and leave you sidelined.
In this article, we’ll discuss why FDA approval isn’t enough to safeguard your innovation, what makes digital health patents unique, and how you can protect your technology before it’s too late.
Why FDA Approval Alone Isn’t Enough
FDA approval is crucial for bringing most digital health products to market, especially in the U.S. It proves that your product meets safety and efficacy standards. However, here’s what it doesn’t do:
Protect Your IP
FDA approval ensures regulatory compliance but does not give you exclusive rights to your technology. Competitors can study your approved product and create similar versions.
Prevent Copycats
Once your product enters the market, others can reverse-engineer it or develop similar solutions, especially if your innovation isn’t protected by patents.
Stop Larger Companies
Big companies with more resources can adapt your idea, build it at scale, and market it more aggressively, pushing your product out of the spotlight.
The Lesson:
FDA approval is a critical step, but it’s not the finish line. To truly safeguard your innovation, you need robust patent protection.
The Unique Challenges of Patenting Digital Health Innovations
Patenting digital health technologies is more complex than traditional medical devices or pharmaceuticals. Here’s why:
Complex Intersections
Digital health combines multiple fields—software, hardware, data analytics, and medicine. Patent claims must cover each of these components effectively.
Algorithm Patentability
Many digital health solutions rely on algorithms or AI models, which are difficult to patent due to legal restrictions on abstract ideas.
Data Dependency
Digital health products often rely on patient data for functionality. Ensuring compliance with privacy laws like HIPAA while protecting your IP can be tricky.
Rapid Innovation
The pace of digital health innovation means that by the time your patent is granted, the technology may have evolved.
The Solution:
Work with experts to navigate these challenges and craft patents that provide meaningful protection.
What Can Be Patented in Digital Health?
Not everything in digital health is patentable. To secure a patent, your innovation must be:
Novel
It must be new and not publicly known.
Non-Obvious
It shouldn’t be something that someone skilled in the field could easily deduce.
Useful
It must solve a specific problem or offer a clear benefit.
Here are examples of patentable aspects in digital health:
Hardware
Devices like wearable monitors or diagnostic tools.
Software
Algorithms for analyzing health data, machine learning models, or decision-support systems.
Methods
Processes for collecting, analyzing, and presenting medical data.
Integration Systems
Technologies that enable seamless communication between devices and platforms.
Pro Tip:
Break down your product into its individual components to identify which aspects are unique and worth patenting.
How to Patent Your Digital Health Innovation
Now that you understand the importance of patents and what can be protected, let’s walk through the steps to secure your IP:
Conduct a Patentability Search
Before filing a patent, ensure that your innovation is truly unique. A patentability search will help you:
Avoid infringing on existing patents.
Identify gaps in the market where your innovation stands out.
Understand the competitive landscape.
File for a Provisional Patent
A provisional patent application is an affordable way to secure your idea while giving you time to refine it. It gives you a “patent pending” status and establishes an early filing date.
Benefits of Provisional Patents:
Lower cost compared to full patents.
Provides a 12-month window to develop and test your product.
Prevents others from filing similar patents during that period.
Action Step:
File a provisional patent as soon as your concept is developed enough to describe clearly.
Craft Detailed Claims
The claims section of your patent is the most critical part. It defines the scope of your protection. For digital health technologies, you need claims that cover:
The specific functionality of your software or algorithm.
The integration of hardware and software.
Unique methods or processes your product uses.
Action Step:
Work with a patent attorney who specializes in digital health to draft precise and defensible claims.
Protect Trade Secrets
Not every aspect of your innovation needs to be patented. Some elements, like proprietary algorithms or datasets, are better kept as trade secrets.
Action Step:
Implement strict confidentiality agreements with employees, contractors, and partners.
File for International Patents
If you plan to market your digital health product globally, you’ll need protection in multiple countries.
Action Step:
Use the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) to file international patents efficiently.
Monitor Competitors
Stay informed about what others in your space are patenting. This helps you:
Avoid infringement.
Identify opportunities to innovate.
Anticipate competitive threats.
Action Step:
Set up alerts using tools like Google Patents or hire a patent monitoring service.
Be Ready to Defend Your Patents
Even with strong protection, disputes can arise. Be prepared to:
Send cease-and-desist letters.
Negotiate licensing agreements.
Take legal action if necessary.
Action Step:
Build a relationship with a trusted patent attorney who can help you enforce your rights.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
When patenting digital health innovations, avoid these pitfalls:
Delaying Patent Filing: Waiting too long increases the risk of someone else filing a similar patent.
Overlooking Software: Don’t assume that algorithms or software can’t be patented—they often can, with the right approach.
Ignoring Data Privacy: Ensure your patent doesn’t conflict with privacy laws like HIPAA.
Filing Narrow Patents: Broad patents provide better protection against competitors.
A Bit About Our Partner - PatentPC, Who Provided This Contribution
At PatentPC, we specialize in helping digital health innovators navigate the complexities of patenting their technologies. Here’s how we can help:
Tailored Patent Strategies: We’ll work with you to identify the most valuable aspects of your technology and craft patents that provide robust protection.
Expert Drafting: Our team understands the unique challenges of digital health patents and can create detailed claims that stand up in court.
Global Reach: Whether you’re targeting the U.S. or international markets, we’ll ensure your IP is secure.
Aggressive Defense: If someone infringes on your patents, we’ll fight to protect your rights.
Conclusion: Protect Your Innovation Before It’s Too Late
Digital health is one of the most exciting and transformative industries today, but it’s also one of the most competitive. FDA approval is essential for bringing your product to market, but it won’t stop competitors from copying your technology.
The solution? Act now. Secure your innovation with patents, protect your trade secrets, and monitor competitors to stay ahead. At PatentPC, we’re here to help you safeguard your hard work and ensure your digital health innovation thrives in the market.
